Skip to content
The Pigeon Test
Book Structures Tool Work with Mark
work with mark contact mark newsletter (opens in a new tab)

About

The Pigeon Test is a companion to Mark Eddleston’s book. It helps you tell apart three kinds of situation. Simple, where cause and effect hold still and the rules settle it; complicated, where they still hold but it takes someone qualified to trace them; and complex, where they only line up looking back, and no plan survives contact.

The cake, rocket and child images are Glouberman and Zimmerman’s (opens in a new tab), not Mark’s own.

A rocket is complicated, decompose it and it’s still a rocket. A brain is complex, decompose it and you’ve destroyed what you were studying.

It is a crude tool and it can be wrong. Treat the reading as a way to look more closely, not a ruling.

Taken as a whole, an organisation is always complex, because it is made of people interacting constantly. The three states are states a complex system can be held in, not three kinds of organisation, and a bureaucracy is a complex one held still. So the tool looks at one situation inside your organisation, and that situation can be any of the three. Some come apart into pieces that behave differently. A plannable part inside a complex one is normal, like the payroll run inside a merger or the data migration inside the culture change.

This tool gives you one opinion. If your situation has parts of different kinds, they get squeezed into one answer, which is one of the ways a crude tool is crude. If part of what you described does not fit the reading, give that part more attention. But be careful about splitting a situation up. What makes something complex is usually in how the parts affect each other, so you can only treat a part on its own if it would behave the same way separated from the rest.

Why this tool?

The skill is knowing which kind of problem you’re facing before you reach for any answer at all. Samir Rihani, whose work the book builds on, put it plainly. Before we rush in with solutions, we have to determine first the nature of the system in question. This tool exists to help with that first step.

Your privacy

Nothing you type here leaves your device unless you choose to send it. An anonymous copy of each result is also kept on your own device.

On the structures pages, the site remembers on your device when it last showed you a small box about the book, so it doesn’t keep showing it. That’s all it remembers, and it isn’t sent anywhere. If your browser blocks this, the box never appears. Clicks on the site’s buy links, and showings of that box, are counted by place and day only, with nothing about who you are.

One thing is sent by default. When you move on from your reading, your answers to the questions, your gut feeling, the kind of situation, the reading and how long each screen took are counted anonymously, without anything you wrote and without your name, email or anything about your device. Mark studies them to understand how people read situations, sometimes with AI tools, and may share them with university researchers. To leave yours out, use the link under your reading.

What you write is sent in only three ways. The first is “Email me my result.” If you use it, your result and your answers to three quick questions about how useful it was are sent and kept, to deliver that result and to look for patterns across situations. Your email address is used to send it. It’s kept only if you also ask for our occasional writing on organisations and complexity, and then separately from the result, never as its identity.

“Ask your team” is the second. If you use it, the situation and next step you share are kept until the link expires thirty days later, along with your own gut feeling and reading, so your private link can show them next to everyone else’s. If you open a link someone else shared, your own gut feeling, answers and reading are sent anonymously to whoever shared it, so they can compare everyone’s readings. These are kept for the same 30 days.

The third is the research box under your reading. If you tick it, your situation, your next step and any note saying the reading felt wrong are added to your counted answers. Names of people and organisations are removed before anything you wrote is shared with researchers. Untick the box and what you wrote is deleted straight away. Later, email the code shown under the box and the whole run will be deleted. Nothing else on this tool sends anything anywhere.

The tool never asks for your name, but an email address is personal too. If you ask for the occasional writing, your address stays on this site only until it’s added to the mailing list, then it’s deleted here. Emailing your result sends your address through Resend, which keeps a delivery record. You can unsubscribe from any email at any time.

Mark Eddleston runs The Pigeon Test. The site runs on Cloudflare, results are emailed through Resend, the writing goes out through Substack and research readings may be studied with Anthropic’s Claude, all based in the US. To see or delete anything held about you, email mark.eddleston@gmail.com. You can also complain to the Information Commissioner’s Office at ico.org.uk (opens in a new tab).

Email me my result

Did the result make sense?
Did it change how you are thinking?
What now?

Anonymised diagnostic responses may be used to improve the tool and analyse patterns across situations. Avoid names or information that identifies individuals or organisations.

Sent. Check your inbox.

Ask your team

This is exactly what will be shared. Edit it now if you want to anonymise anything before it goes out.

Whoever opens the link reads this exact text and answers independently. They never see your gut feeling, your answers or your reading. Their anonymous answers come back to you, next to your own reading.

Send this link to your team, or to everyone involved. It stays open for 30 days.

Keep the private link. It’s the only way back to this comparison, and it isn’t shown anywhere else.