The Pigeon Test

Five workshops

The Pigeon Test: Structures

If we don’t engage with complexity, we don’t understand the world around us.

Where to start, and what’s here

Five workshop structures for groups who want to work out, from their own evidence, what kind of work they are actually doing. Start with Same Plan, Ten Times. It needs no preparation or reading, and it hands a group the distinction every other structure here assumes, between work that gives the same result twice and work that doesn’t. If you only ever run one of these, run that one.

Five structures

  1. 01Same Plan, Ten TimesSort the work your organisation does by whether the same plan would give the same result twice, then mark how much of it was planned as though it would.60 min
  2. 02As It ArrivedTrace what your organisation did to the practices it imported from elsewhere, and find out which of them people still follow when nobody is looking.60 min
  3. 03Smaller Than ThatHelp each other move on a change that’s stuck, in threes, under a rule that forbids adding anything new.50 min
  4. 04Several at OnceRun several small ideas for a challenge side by side instead of choosing between them, and let time and energy do the selecting.60 min
  5. 05Without Being AskedFind the places where people already talk to each other usefully without anyone arranging it, then work out what is keeping those places energised.60 min

Why these exist

I nearly left these out of the book. One argument in it is that we keep applying linear recipes to complex situations, and that the people selling the recipes, me included, keep doing it because recipes sell. So there is something off about arriving at the end of it and handing you five workshop structures. Here comes the next framework, dressed up as the cure for frameworks.

I have two defences, and I’m not certain that either holds. The first is that they don’t tell you what to do. Each one starts from your own work, in your own handwriting, and asks a question your group answers from its own evidence. There’s no need for me in the room, or the book. Nobody has to have read a word of it and nobody has to utter the word complexity. Whatever comes out of it says something about your context, and I don’t supply any answers (or patterns).

The second is that they refuse what the recipes promise. There’s no end state in any of them. No roadmap, no date, no maturity model, no report. Two of them finish by making something smaller than anyone wanted it to be, and one finishes by asking a group to protect something nobody ever planned. Whether that adds up to honouring the argument or quietly breaking it, I don’t know. I’ll let you be the judge of that.

They’re early in their development. They’ve been tested with teams, and the testing continues. Each time a group uses one I learn something, usually that a timing doesn’t work or a question invites flattering answers, and now and then that a step had too much instruction or too little. So they’ll keep being adapted, and the versions printed in the book will soon be out of date. These are the latest, and they get corrected here as groups run them and tell me what broke. They’re free and always will be. If you try one, I’d love to hear how it went, especially the bit that didn’t work. Write to me at mark.eddleston@gmail.com.

Before you run one

Three things share the pigeon’s name, and it’s worth separating them before you start. The book is the argument. The Pigeon Test is a free tool that helps you read a situation. You answer a set of questions about something you’re about to do, and it comes back with simple, complicated or complex, and what that reading means for the move you were planning. It tells you where you are rather than what to do, and the reading expires, because situations move. It’s open now, in beta. The Pigeon Test Structures are for groups and none of them hands back a reading. Same Plan, Ten Times comes closest to the tool, sorting a team or organisation’s work by the distinction the tool reads one situation at a time. The other four work with what follows from it.

The pigeon itself, which all three are named after, is the metaphor the book is built on. Launch a ball and you can work out where it will land; launch a pigeon and where it lands cannot be predicted. Simple and complicated work is the ball, and complex work is the pigeon. Three of the structures are run standing up at a wall, sorting sticky notes (Same Plan, Ten Times; As It Arrived; Without Being Asked). Two are run seated, in small groups (Smaller Than That; Several at Once). The walls deliver their finding once per group; the seated ones give you something different every time. Pick from them like a menu, and don’t run more than two in a day.

You don’t need to be a facilitator to run these. Somebody keeps time and asks the questions in the instructions, and that’s the whole job. Foursomes are two pairs joined; a leftover pair or single folds into the nearest foursome, and a five or six just argues harder. Each has a variation, under Riffs and variations, for groups who have read the book. If they haven’t, skip it; the structures work without the book’s argument. Notes on running them well, including timings, the most senior person in the room and running them online, are in Running them well.

If you’d rather I ran one with your group, see work with Mark.

Where the format comes from

The format is borrowed from Liberating Structures (opens in a new tab), a fantastic free collection of ways to run a room, put together by Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless. I’ve been using them for years and I can’t name anything that has done more for healthy human interactions in the groups I’ve worked with.

They’re inspired by complexity science, which I’d argue helps explain why they work so well. Their authors describe them as starting from a hunch that what we know about how living systems organise themselves might translate into how people work together. Complexity isn’t the only ingredient, and several of the individual structures take influence from other fields, but it’s a foundation.

A Liberating Structure sets a handful of simple rules about who talks to whom and for how long, then gets out of the way and lets a group produce something nobody in it designed. The formats we tend to use in rooms don’t do that. A presentation or a managed discussion holds people too tightly, while an open discussion or a brainstorm can be a free-for-all. In different ways, all of them tend to limit who gets to participate and how.

Crucially, they don’t need a professional facilitator, which is the best part of their design. They’re deliberately simple, so that anyone can run one without training. That was the standard I tried to hold these five to. Mine are written in the style of Liberating Structures but aren’t part of the official repertoire, and any flaws are my own. Each structure ends with a note saying where it came from.

Attribution

The Pigeon Test Structures, by Mark Eddleston, made in the style of Liberating Structures, developed by Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless. Not part of the official Liberating Structures repertoire. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (opens in a new tab) (CC BY-SA 4.0), the same licence as Liberating Structures.

The book behind these

These come out of The Pigeon Test: Why Change Fails, which makes the argument for them. Buy it on Amazon (opens in a new tab).