The Pigeon Test
Structure · 50 min03 / 05

Smaller Than That

Get unstuck without adding anything new.

What is made possible

People help each other move on changes that aren’t going the way the plan said, under a rule that bans adding anything new. Everyone leaves with one probe they can start without permission. And everyone notices how often they were about to hand somebody a solution.

Five structural elements (min specs)

Structuring invitation.

Invite the group to bring a change that isn’t going the way the plan said, their own or one they’re watching others struggle with, and to help each other move on it without adding anything new. The wording is in the Intro step, below.

Space and materials.

Chairs in threes, no tables. One card per triad, where all three can see it, with this written on it and nothing else.

No new things. No new practice, tool, meeting or framework.

Questions only, three kinds.

Smaller. What is the smallest version that could teach you something by Friday?

Remove. What could you stop, or loosen, without asking anyone?

Watch. How would you know whether what you try is working, or making things worse?

About to suggest something? Ask one of these instead.

Participation distribution.

Everyone presents once and helps twice. The facilitator states the rule and keeps time; the card does the policing. Three people or more; a bigger group runs several triads at once. A leftover pair runs two rounds with one helper each time. A spare person joins a triad to make a foursome, which runs four shorter rounds in the same time (2, 5 and 2 minutes).

Group configuration.

Triads, three rounds, roles rotating. Everyone together at the end.

Steps and time allocation

  1. 3 min

    Intro. Give the invitation. “Think of a change you’re part of right now that isn’t going the way the plan said. If nothing springs to mind, bring something you’re watching others struggle with; it works just as well. We’re going to help each other, and nobody is allowed to add anything. Help has to make the thing smaller, take away something that’s holding it back, or work out how you’d notice whether it’s working. Everything else, keep to yourself.” Then read the card aloud once.

  2. 3 min

    Tell it. In each triad, one person presents first. They describe the change and say what’s happening, not why they think it’s happening. The other two listen.

  3. 6 min

    Three questions. The two helpers ask questions only, the three on the card. A helper who catches themselves about to suggest something keeps it to themselves, asks one of the card’s questions instead, and remembers the suggestion for the end.

  4. 3 min

    Commit. The presenter names one probe, either a smaller version of the change or something they’ll stop or loosen. It has to be small enough to start without permission and stop without a meeting. They also name the sign they’ll watch for to tell whether it’s working, and the sign that would make them stop it. No date, no promised end state. Then they name somebody outside this room they’ll tell about it.

  5. 24 min

    Rotate. Two more rounds, roles rotating, so everyone presents once.

  6. 7 min

    The almost-saids. Everyone together. Ask, “What did you almost say?” Go round the room. Each person says how many suggestions they swallowed, and names one. No solving, no defending. Keep a running total where everyone can see it, on fingers if there’s nothing else. Say the total back to the room and ask, “What would have happened if you’d said them?” Then say nothing.

Call it fifty minutes with chair shuffling.

Practice insights

  • Tips

    The ban is the structure, and when it slips the triad turns into free consulting and the presenter leaves with homework instead of a probe. The presenter may ask the helpers what to do; the only answer the card allows is another question. Watch for additions wearing question marks, because “have you considered a retro?” is a suggestion. In Commit, the sign that would make the presenter stop the probe often gets skipped because it sounds defeatist. Hold the presenter to it.

  • Riffs and variations

    For a group that has read the book, say what the card is doing. “Every new practice, tool or framework is another lever. The card stops anyone pulling one.”

  • Practical applications

    Wherever a room has just seen a problem clearly and is now hungry for a method. It works well straight after Same Plan, Ten Times, with each presenter bringing a dotted right-zone sticky from that wall that they’re part of.

  • Optional Liberating Structures string

    Reconvene with What, So What, Now What (opens in a new tab) once the probes have had time to show something; suggest a fortnight, but let the group choose. For a situation that needs advice rather than shrinking, hand it to Troika Consulting (opens in a new tab), this one’s more generous sibling.

Where it came from

Built on Troika Consulting (opens in a new tab), which runs the same rotation without the ban. The rule that you can start a probe without permission comes from 15% Solutions (opens in a new tab).

The book behind these

These come out of The Pigeon Test: Why Change Fails, which makes the argument for them. Buy it on Amazon (opens in a new tab). If you’d rather I ran this one with your group, see work with Mark.