As It Arrived
Find out what your organisation did to the ways of working it imported.
What is made possible
An organisation’s import history ends up on one wall, sorted into three zones, kept as it arrived, changed into its own version, or gone. Then the room marks which parts of it people still do when nobody is looking.
Five structural elements (min specs)
Structuring invitation.
Invite the group to think of the practices, frameworks and ways of working the organisation brought in from somewhere else, and to find out what this place did to them. The words to use are in the Intro step.
Space and materials.
A wall with three zones marked in tape, left, middle and right, unlabelled. Sticky notes, pens, dot stickers. Room for everyone to stand at the wall together.
Participation distribution.
Writing, sorting and dotting are everybody’s, and nobody’s stickies outrank anybody else’s. The facilitator asks the questions and then keeps out of the way. Eight people up.
Group configuration.
Alone, then pairs, then foursomes, then everyone, then foursomes again.
Steps and time allocation
- 2 min
Intro. Give the invitation. “Think of the practices, frameworks and ways of working this organisation brought in from somewhere else. Things like stand-ups, Agile, the engagement survey, the operating model with a Scandinavian name. We’re going to find out what we did to them, and which ones are still going.”
- 4 min
Write alone. Each person writes practices that arrived here from somewhere else, one per sticky. Only things that were adopted. E.g. retros, the nine-box grid, the survey, the framework a consultant brought.
- 5 min
Pairs. Combine your stickies and keep the eight most specific. Before a sticky goes up, write two things on it, where it came from and the year it arrived. A guess at the year is fine. No source, no sticky.
- 16 min
The sort. Pairs join into foursomes and take their stickies to the wall. Ask, “Is it done today the way it arrived?” Left zone, yes. Middle zone, changed into your own version. Right zone, gone, nobody does any version of it at all. Between left and middle, ask whether whoever sold it would recognise what you do now. Between middle and gone, if any corner still does a version, it’s middle. Contested ones get two minutes and then they land. Draw a line under any sticky that used the full two minutes.
- 7 min
Second pass. Still in foursomes, nothing moves. Ask a new question of every sticky in the left and middle zones. “Do people do it when nobody is checking?” Only sightings count; if the only evidence is the calendar invite or the dashboard, that’s checking. If yes, it gets a dot.
- 12 min
Stand back. Everyone. Ask, “What do you notice about where the dots are?” Then set a timer for two minutes of silence for everyone to think and write one thing they notice on a sticky. Then go round the room, each person reading theirs out, with no commentary.
- 9 min
It came from here. Back into the same foursomes. Each foursome picks one dotted sticky from the middle zone. Ask, “What does your version know that the original didn’t?” Name it, and name who worked it out, because it didn’t change by itself.
An hour, allowing for movement and stragglers.
Practice insights
- Tips
Keep the sort question concrete. Ask “Was the rollout successful?” instead, and people defend practices they championed rather than report what happened to them. The same discipline holds on the dots, where “people love it” is an intention and the question asked for sightings. A left-zone sticky with no dot is done exactly as it arrived, but only while somebody is checking. Don’t point it out; the room will notice it at the stand back. And if the gone zone comes back nearly empty, don’t celebrate, look at the years. Organisations delete their failures, and a wall where nothing is older than three years is a graveyard with the headstones taken out.
- Riffs and variations
For a group that has read the book, point at the left zone at the end and say, “Everything here was worked out by another organisation to fit its own situation. What arrived was a snapshot, and theirs has probably changed since. We’re still running the snapshot.”
- Practical applications
When the next import is being proposed, before it’s rolled out. When a practice is about to be scrapped for not being done properly, because the wall may show it has been changed into the organisation’s own version rather than failed.
- Optional Liberating Structures string
Carry a dotted middle-zone sticky into Shift & Share (opens in a new tab), so the people who rebuilt it can show the room how it actually runs. Or take a contested sticky into Simple Ethnography (opens in a new tab) and go and watch the thing before anyone rules on it.
Where it came from
Not built on anything in the official repertoire.
The book behind these
These come out of The Pigeon Test: Why Change Fails, which makes the argument for them. Buy it on Amazon (opens in a new tab). If you’d rather I ran this one with your group, see work with Mark.