Several at Once
Try several small experiments at once instead of picking one.
What is made possible
A challenge the group is stuck on gets a mix of small experiments, instead of a meeting picking one solution and backing it. Everyone’s private bet on which will work goes into a sealed envelope, and at the reconvene the room can put what it expected next to what happened.
Five structural elements (min specs)
Structuring invitation.
Invite the group to pick a challenge it’s stuck on and come up with several small, deliberately different experiments to start at once. The wording is in the Intro step, below.
Space and materials.
Chairs, index cards, pens, and an envelope for each group. Somewhere to write the challenge sentence where everyone can see it, and a flat surface for laying out cards; the floor will do. One card per foursome with the four tests from The tests step written on it.
Participation distribution.
Everyone writes, tests and bets, and anyone may end up owning an experiment, as long as it’s one they can start without asking anyone. The facilitator writes up the challenge sentence and keeps time, and leaves judging the experiments to the four tests. Four people or more.
Group configuration.
Everyone, then alone, then pairs, then foursomes, then everyone, with a moment alone for the envelope.
Steps and time allocation
- 3 min
Intro. Give the invitation. “Think of a challenge this group is stuck on. We’re going to come up with several small experiments, as different from each other as we can make them. We’ll meet again, probably in a fortnight or so, to see what they’re showing us. Nobody picks a winner today. At the end you’ll each write down, privately, which one you think will work. That doesn’t decide anything, because they all still run, but when we meet again we’ll see how good our guesses were.”
- 5 min
The challenge. Ask the room to agree one sentence describing the challenge it’s stuck on, and write it up. If more than one challenge comes up, write each one up in a different part of the room and ask people to go and stand by the one they’re stuck on. With eight or more people, split into one group per challenge that has at least four people standing by it; anyone else joins their second choice. Each group runs the rest of the structure with its own sentence, spread and envelope. With fewer than eight, go with the challenge that has the most people standing by it. Test the sentence aloud. “Does it already contain a solution?” “People are drowning in meetings” passes. “How do we get everyone using the new system?” fails, because the new system is already the answer. Rewrite until it passes.
- 5 min
Write alone. Each person writes as many experiments as they can, one per index card, each starting “We could try…”, each small enough to start. Range beats quality, so include one you don’t quite believe in.
- 5 min
Pairs. Pool your cards. Merge true duplicates only. Keep the strange ones.
- 15 min
The tests. Pairs join into foursomes and pool their cards. Read each one aloud and run it through the four tests on the foursome’s card. “Small enough that losing it costs little? Fast enough to teach us something by the time we meet again? Stoppable without a meeting? Would we notice it working, or making things worse? If it fails a test, shrink it until it passes, or bin it.” Put binned cards in a pile where everyone can see them.
- 7 min
The spread. Everyone together. Lay all the surviving cards on the flat surface. Two volunteers build the spread while the room watches, starting with the two cards most unlike each other and laying out every other card between them, nearer whichever it’s more like. Any two that turn out to be the same experiment get merged. No votes, no ranking. The only objection allowed is “Those two are too alike.” If someone asks which is best, the answer is “Ask me when we meet again.”
- 3 min
The envelope. Alone, each person writes on an index card the one experiment in the spread they privately expect to work. Their own is allowed, and so is “none of them”. Put the cards in the envelope and seal it. One person keeps it, and it’s opened at the reconvene before anyone reports.
- 7 min
Claim and watch. Every experiment in the spread gets an owner who can start it without asking anyone, and two signs, one that would say it’s working and one that would say it’s making things worse. Write the owner and both signs on the card. Agree one reconvene date for all of them. Suggest a fortnight, but let the group choose a date by which every experiment could be showing something. The reconvene isn’t a verdict; any experiment that isn’t making things worse keeps running. Each owner names somebody outside the room they’ll tell about it. No owner, no experiment.
An hour with movement.
Practice insights
- Tips
The challenge sentence is where this succeeds or fails, so hold the room to the test. The four tests are pass or fail, and a full bin means they’re being applied properly. If the spread comes out samey, the room has used “too alike” to vote without admitting it; split the merged cards back out. There is no dot pass here, deliberately, because dots pick winners. Opened early, the envelope turns into lobbying. A “none of them” card is a bet like any other. At the reconvene, watch for the room treating early results as final; a slow starter can look like a failure at the first look. If nothing survives Claim and watch because nobody can start anything without permission, stop, and spend the rest of the session on why.
- Riffs and variations
For a group that has read the book, point at the spread at the end and say, “Nobody picked. The choosing has moved from this meeting to what happens next, and the envelope will show whether we’d have chosen well. A system with plenty of variety can cope with conditions nobody saw coming. One that picks a single answer only has that answer.”
- Practical applications
Straight after Same Plan, Ten Times, when one right-zone sticky is the one everyone’s stuck on. When a stalled programme is about to be relaunched bigger.
- Optional Liberating Structures string
At the reconvene, open the envelope first, then go through what happened with What, So What, Now What (opens in a new tab).
Where it came from
15% Solutions (opens in a new tab), for the rule that every experiment has to be something its owner can start without permission. The sizing comes from Chapter 7 of the book, with each experiment small enough that failure costs little, and enough of them that some will land.
The book behind these
These come out of The Pigeon Test: Why Change Fails, which makes the argument for them. Buy it on Amazon (opens in a new tab). If you’d rather I ran this one with your group, see work with Mark.