Without Being Asked
Find where the talking already happens, and what keeps it alive.
What is made possible
Somewhere in this organisation, people already talk to each other usefully without anyone arranging it. A group finds as much of it as it can and works out what is keeping those places alive. None of it was anybody’s idea, so none of it is in anybody’s plan.
Five structural elements (min specs)
Structuring invitation.
Invite the group to think about where people in the organisation talk to each other usefully without anyone organising it, and to work out what keeps that alive. The wording is in the Intro step, below.
Space and materials.
A wall with two zones marked in tape, left and right, unlabelled. Sticky notes, pens, dot stickers in one colour. Room for everyone to stand at the wall together.
Participation distribution.
The whole room writes, sorts and dots. The facilitator asks the questions and otherwise stays out of it. Eight people up.
Group configuration.
Alone, then pairs, then foursomes, then everyone, then foursomes again.
Steps and time allocation
- 3 min
Intro. Give the invitation. “Think about where in this organisation people actually talk to each other usefully, without anyone organising it. The corridor. The group chat. The two teams who sort things out between themselves. The person everybody rings. We’re going to find all of it, and then work out what’s keeping it alive.” Point at the two taped zones without explaining them. Before anyone writes, say that some of what goes on this wall is happening in spite of an arrangement somebody standing here made, and that this is what we came to find.
- 5 min
Write alone. Each person writes places where people talk usefully without being asked to, one per sticky. Name the actual thing. Who, where, about what. Not general words like “collaboration”. E.g. the Tuesday coffee, or the two engineers who ignore the ticketing system and just ring each other.
- 5 min
Pairs. Combine your stickies and keep the eight most specific. One test before a sticky goes to the wall. Nobody set this up. If somebody did, leave it off.
- 14 min
The sort. Pairs join into foursomes and take their stickies to the wall. Ask, “If this organisation reorganised next month, with new managers and new tools, would this survive?” Left zone, would survive. Right zone, wouldn’t. Two minutes for the contested ones, then they land. Draw a line under any sticky that used the full two minutes.
- 8 min
Second pass. Still in foursomes, nothing moves. Ask the foursomes to put one new question to every sticky in both zones. “What is keeping this alive?” They’re looking for what protects it, not who is in it. For example, somebody senior who shields it, a budget nobody has noticed, a room, a shared history, or the fact that nobody upstairs knows it exists. Write the protector on the sticky. If they can’t name one, it gets a dot. A dot here means unprotected and nothing more.
- 10 min
Stand back. Everyone. Ask, “What do you notice about where the dots are?” Then set a timer for two minutes of silence for everyone to think and write one thing they notice on a sticky. Then go round the room, each person reading theirs out, with no commentary.
- 8 min
Keep one alive. Back into the same foursomes. Each foursome picks one dotted sticky. Ask, “What is the smallest thing somebody here could do to make it more likely to survive the next reorganisation, without formalising it, naming it, funding it or putting it on a slide?” Name who will do it, and that person names somebody outside this room they’ll tell about it. No date.
An hour once people have shuffled about.
Practice insights
- Tips
The nobody-set-this-up test keeps the wall from filling with guilds and communities of practice, which are somebody’s initiative and belong somewhere else. Say twice that a dot means unprotected rather than important, because the room will read it the other way round the first time. Within about a minute of the second pass, somebody will want to take one of these places and roll it out across the organisation. Once it’s rolled out, it’s an import like any other, and As It Arrived shows what happens to those. If the room can’t name a protector for most of the wall, it has found an organisation one reorganisation away from losing most of the conversations it runs on. Encourage the sticky somebody hesitates over; it’s usually the best one on the wall.
- Riffs and variations
For a group that has read the book, give them Sami’s line from Chapter 7, “No interactions, no progress”, then ask, “What keeps this organisation’s interactions going?” The wall is the answer.
To come at the same question from the opposite direction, run Creative Destruction (TRIZ) (opens in a new tab) instead. Design the organisation where nobody can usefully talk to anybody, go down the list marking everything you already do, then stop one of them. It works on a wall too. Build the design in one zone, then physically move into the second zone everything that turns out to be true, which lands harder than writing a second list. It’s a much harder conversation than this one, so know your group before you reach for it.
- Practical applications
Before a reorganisation is drawn, while there’s still time to draw it around these places rather than through them. When somebody proposes a communications workstream, or when two organisations are being integrated and nobody has asked what the merger will step on.
- Optional strings
Run it straight after Same Plan, Ten Times, starting from whatever that structure’s last question found working without a plan. Or take a dotted sticky into Liberating Structures’ Discovery and Action Dialogue (opens in a new tab), so the people in it can say what they do that keeps it going.
Where it came from
It stands near Discovery and Action Dialogue (opens in a new tab) and Appreciative Interviews (opens in a new tab) without being built on either. The idea of going to look for what already works, rather than for what is broken, belongs to the positive deviance tradition of Jerry and Monique Sternin.
The book behind these
These come out of The Pigeon Test: Why Change Fails, which makes the argument for them. Buy it on Amazon (opens in a new tab). If you’d rather I ran this one with your group, see work with Mark.